Matching by color name alone is risky, and your hunch is correct. When we needed carpet in Kent WA to match an older room, Intra Flooring explained that Iron Frost appears in more than one of their collections: in the Alpine collection it’s listed as AP-9 and in Camden as CN-6. Same color name, but the construction and look can differ. They asked us to bring a label, the old invoice or a leftover piece, which gave a much more reliable starting point than photos. For stairs, double-check that the exact product is approved for stair use and ask which cushion they recommend. We found our original invoice in a drawer, and the match turned out very close. Do you still have any leftover scraps from the original install?